Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Black Lives Don't Matter

This piece is in response to the recent riots in Baltimore MD after the death of another man at the hands of the police.  http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/29/us/baltimore-riots.html?_r=0


I am a male.  I am white.  I am tired. 

Black lives don’t matter.  Lives matter.

I realize that my skin color and gender leave me rather unqualified to answer in true empathy.  I will never be able to place myself in the shoes of black-American.

Bias and prejudice may need to be violently fought; it seems at certain times in history this true.  But I feel that now is not the time for that,  at least not in this Country of “opportunity”.  There are perhaps not enough opportunities for every citizen, but we not at risk of running out of opportunities yet.  Too many people simply opt out.  In this country bias and prejudice should be fought not with violence, but with action.  Show that you are a capable black leader.  Show that you are a respectful (not subservient) black citizen.   Show that you’re a loving black father.  If you are those things, then remove the prefix “black”.  You are a capable leader, you are a respectful citizen, you are a loving father.  We don’t say “he is such a good White leader” (though some might think it.)  The wars that are being fought are largely self-inflicted now.  The work of the previous generations being largely undone. 

“…Tha Police.” (N.W.A. 1988)

There are wicked people in this world.  Your job (Police, Military, Doctors, Teachers, Lawyers etc.) doesn’t make you good or bad; you are a person (Black, white, all that) who is responsible to act well.  It doesn’t surprise or shock me that there are persons in the Police force who make bad decisions; wicked decisions even.  They should be punished. 

Most of the national cases of Police brutality against black citizens (at last as reported in the media) seem to indicate fault on the side of the Police Officer.  But it is worth pointing out that the Black men (and woman?) who are unjustifiably being beaten and killed, are not fully innocent, or at least not intelligent.  This is not to say they DESERVE to be beaten and killed, but the fault is not fully on the side of the Police.  Many have made aggressive actions towards the officers, many have fled, or resisted.  This is either an indication of unlawful action, or stupidity.  An intelligent person would not unnecessarily put himself or herself at risk by running from a Police Officer, especially with the current trend of police using unnecessary force. 

The Nation seems at risk, with city after city falling to these headline killings and lootings.  Body cameras on the Police Officer’s are a short game fix that would probably help.  But the problem runs deeper, and farther back.  Precautions at the Officer/Victim level are insufficient. 

The problems are probably too big to be solved with blustering, or policy.  We need personal reform.  We need citizens working together.  We need Black and White people working hard until the terms are no longer important.  There needs to be personal, as well as organizational accountability.  Stop being racist.  Easy right?

I honestly don’t know what the solution is.  But I am tired of hearing the same story; the same story from both sides.  Seek Justice, but more importantly, seek progress.  This is largely an American problem.  Let’s look at the success stories of other integrated countries, lets talk to each other honestly.  Let’s swallow our own preconceptions and live next to each other.  I am a white man who lives in a predominantly black neighborhood and I am glad for it.  I begin to see that these people (color irrelevant) are my neighbors.  Some are good, some are kind.  Some are disrespectful and rude, some are threatening.  We are all people, silly people. 


Black lives don’t matter.  Lives matter. 

Thursday, April 23, 2015

Human Genetic Engineering is Here

Genetic engineering has long been a staple of Science Fiction paranoia.  If not the major theme of a story, it often shows up in ancillary roles, normally to a negative effect.  The stories in books and films often have served as a warning sign for how genetic engineering could go wrong.
A recent article in Nature announced that Chinese scientist produced a paper wherein they explained the “successful” genetic engineering of “non-viable” human embryos which recently took place.  The scientists used a genetic modification technique known as CRISPR/Cas9 to modify a gene in the genome responsible for a fatal blood disorder.  
So what is the ethical problem with genetic engineering?  The Science Fiction dystopian futures aside, some would argue that, while the intentions are initially good (eradicate genetic diseases), the capability could be used in the future to artificially control for desirable characteristics and features and we are not yet sure, as a society, if we are ok with that.  What is our role in controlling important aspects of a human being?  It is not difficult to imagine a future where good intentions are perverted for abuse.  For example, individuals bred for their athletic ability (sports and war), or individuals bred to be complacent and low-thinking (slavery).   
It is a difficult dance that scientist often are required to perform.  On the one hand, their objective is to discover and push boundaries. On the other hand, are they responsible for the evil that is done as a result of their work?  Another difficult question: are WE responsible for benefiting from the vile practices of old.  Medical science has advanced throughout history through many horrific events such as murders to provide bodies for dissections, Nazi experiments etc.
We will certainly see more of these stories as time goes on.  



Friday, April 10, 2015

North Charleston Shooting

Recently here in North Charleston S.C. we had a police shooting incident that made national news.  The officer made a traffic stop for a tail-light being out.  The man stopped ran on foot and was shot several times in the back.  The officer made a statement that he felt his life in danger.  He has since been charged with murder.  This is on the heels of several other national cases where a police shooting has caused tension between the Police and the public.  One of the interesting aspects of this case is that the report the officer gave, seems to disagree with video footing that was turned in by a nearby bystander who shot the incident on his cell phone.  This evidence led to a swift charge of murder for the officer.  The mayor of North Charleston has ordered that all police officers will now wear body cameras.


I do not envy the stress and tension being a police officer in certain areas entails.  I can not fairly imagine how I would respond in any given circumstance.  However, it is hard to conclude that in any way the officer SHOULD have felt his life in danger.  On all accounts the murdered individual was fleeing, not acting aggressively.  Beyond the poor choice to use inappropriate force, the officer also filed a false report in order to cover for his mistake.  He inflated the story to present a sympathetic situation.  Without the video evidence, it is likely the officer would have been trusted and justice not served.